The following lists outline the top ten finishers in the Doig Medal count since 1995.
| 1995 | 1996 | 1997 |
|---|---|---|
| Peter Mann 97 | Stephen O'Reilly 102 | Dale Kickett 93 |
| Dale Kickett 73 | Dale Kickett 81 | Shane Parker 76 |
| Ben Allan 64 | Scott Chisholm 70 | Craig Callaghan 74 |
| Scott Chisholm 61 | Peter Mann 43 | Andrew Wills 72 |
| Stephen O'Reilly 54 | Craig Callaghan 35 | Greg Harding 63 |
| Matthew Burton 39 | Gavin Mitchell 33 | Luke Toia 55 |
| Scott Watters 33 | Luke Toia 32 | Stephen O'Reilly 33 |
| Craig Callaghan 30 | Daniel Bandy 30 | Quenton Leach 26 |
| Jason Norrish 29 | Anthony Jones 29 | Gary Dhurrkay 24 |
| Quenton Leach 27 | Shaun McManus 25 | Mark Gale 23 |
| 1998 | 1999 | 2000 |
|---|---|---|
| Jason Norrish 73 | Adrian Fletcher 128 | Troy Cook 167 |
| Adrian Fletcher 72 | Tony Modra 60 | Paul Hasleby 124 |
| Craig Callaghan 71 | Daniel Bandy 39 | Clive Waterhouse 112 |
| Chris Bond 67 | Dale Kickett 39 | Daniel Bandy 93 |
| Shane Parker 61 | Clive Waterhouse 39 | Adrian Fletcher 71 |
| Matthew Burton 47 | Shane Parker 36 | Shaun McManus 65 |
| Brad Dodd 37 | Heath Black 35 | Shane Parker 60 |
| Mark Gale 36 | Ashley Prescott 33 | Troy Longmuir 55 |
| Dale Kickett 36 | James Clement 30 | Matthew Pavlich 54 |
| Jess Sinclair 30 | Clem Michael 28 | Tony Modra 45 |
| 2001 | 2002 | 2003 |
|---|---|---|
| Peter Bell 153 | Matthew Pavlich 99 | Peter Bell 110 |
| Heath Black 109 | Peter Bell 91 | Matthew Pavlich 107 |
| Matthew Carr 97 | Shane Parker 89 | Paul Hasleby 97 |
| Matthew Pavlich 95 | Paul Hasleby 86 | Robert Haddrill 93 |
| Troy Cook 86 | Troy Simmonds 85 | Shaun McManus 91 |
| Shane Parker 80 | Matthew Carr 84 | Matthew Carr 89 |
| Justin Longmuir 79 | Antoni Grover 83 | James Walker 88 |
| Anthony Jones 76 | James Walker 81 | Paul Medhurst 87 |
| Paul Hasleby 73 | Justin Longmuir 77 | Dion Woods 84 |
| Adrian Fletcher 56 | Shaun McManus 76 | Roger Hayden 84 |
| 2004 | 2005 | 2006 |
|---|---|---|
| Peter Bell 36 | Matthew Pavlich 47 | Matthew Pavlich 34 |
| Paul Hasleby 34 | Peter Bell 25 | Peter Bell 31 |
| Matthew Pavlich 33 | Shane Parker 25 | Michael Johnson 31 |
| Justin Longmuir 28 | Heath Black 23 | Shane Parker 28 |
| Luke McPharlin 27 | Paul Hasleby 22 | Josh Carr 25 |
| Shane Parker 27 | Scott Thornton 22 | Aaron Sandilands 25 |
| Robert Haddrill 26 | Jeff Farmer 21 | Jeff Farmer 23 |
| Jeff Farmer 23 | Antoni Grover 20 | David Mundy 21 |
| Paul Medhurst 22 | Justin Longmuir 20 | Steven Dodd 21 |
| Troy Simmonds 21 | Luke McPharlin 20 | Luke McPharlin/Matthew Carr 20 |
| 2007 | 2008 | 2009 |
|---|---|---|
| Matthew Pavlich 29 | Matthew Pavlich 30 | Aaron Sandilands 132 |
| Antoni Grover 24 | Aaron Sandilands 27 | Matthew Pavlich 112 |
| Luke McPharlin 22 | Luke McPharlin 26 | Chris Tarrant 89 |
| Peter Bell 21 | Rhys Palmer 23 | Paul Duffield 75 |
| Roger Hayden 21 | Michael Johnson 21 | Paul Hasleby 68 |
| Josh Carr 21 | Ryan Crowley 21 | David Mundy 68 |
| Dean Solomon 21 | David Mundy 16 | Stephen Hill 62 |
| Des Headland 20 | Byron Schammer 14 | Greg Broughton 52 |
| Heath Black 17 | Roger Hayden 12 | Garrick Ibbotson 43 |
| Michael Johnson 17 | Garrick Ibbotson 11 | Steven Dodd 35 |
| 2010 | 2011 | 2012 |
|---|---|---|
| David Mundy 190 | Matthew Pavlich 144 | Ryan Crowley 146 |
| Aaron Sandilands 171 | Nathan Fyfe 141 | Chris Mayne 142 |
| Matthew Pavlich 160 | Greg Broughton 118 | Michael Johnson 136 |
| Stephen Hill 137 | Luke McPharlin 108 | Matthew Pavlich 136 |
| Greg Broughton 116 | David Mundy 102 | Luke McPharlin 135 |
| Hayden Ballantyne 103 | Aaron Sandilands 98 | David Mundy 131 |
| Michael Barlow 97 | Stephen Hill 94 | Stephen Hill 130 |
| Chris Tarrant 80 | Antoni Grover 88 | Matthew de Boer 129 |
| Roger Hayden 78 | Hayden Ballantyne 83 | Michael Barlow 128 |
| Luke McPharlin 76 | Chris Mayne 72 | Clancee Pearce 126 |
| 2013 | 2014 | 2015 |
|---|---|---|
| Nathan Fyfe 263 | Nathan Fyfe 283 | Aaron Sandilands 282 |
| David Mundy 246 | Aaron Sandilands 251 | David Mundy 277 |
| Michael Johnson 239 | Stephen Hill 238 | Stephen Hill 261 |
| Ryan Crowley 238 | David Mundy 219 | Nathan Fyfe 260 |
| Lee Spurr 226 | Hayden Ballantyne 209 | Michael Walters 244 |
| Chris Mayne 219 | Michael Barlow 205 | Lachie Neale 239 |
| Michael Barlow 216 | Cameron Sutcliffe 198 | Lee Spurr 223 |
| Hayden Ballantyne 192 | Lee Spurr 193 | Danyle Pearce 217 |
| Michael Walters 186 | Danyle Pearce 190 | Chris Mayne 202 |
| Tendai Mzungu 180 | Michael Johnson 179 | Luke McPharlin 198 |
| 2016 | 2017 | 2018 |
|---|---|---|
| Lachie Neale 200 | ||
| Stephen Hill 170 | ||
| Michael Walters 152 | ||
| Matthew Pavlich 118 | ||
| Lee Spurr 116 | ||
| Chris Mayne 99 | ||
| Hayden Ballantyne 85 | ||
| Michael Barlow 80 | ||
| David Mundy 75 | ||
| Tommy Sheridan 65 |